Skip to content
AuCom provides comprehensive motor control solutions for both Low Voltage and Medium Voltage applications, including Soft Starters, Drives, and Motor Control Centres.
aucom_emx4_products_header
AuCom specialises in delivering tailored motor control solutions across a wide range of industries, from HVAC to Oil & Gas, to Mining & Quarrying.
aucom_mining_industries_header
In addition to our product range, AuCom provides specialised services to support the smooth and efficient operation of your systems.
aucom_field-support_services_header
Explore our comprehensive resources, from product guides to technical insights, designed to support and empower your operations.
aucom_brochure_resources_header
Whether you need to contact our team, find support, or connect with our global network, AuCom is here to help anytime, anywhere.
aucom_hotline_contact_header
19 November 20266 min read

DOL vs. Star-Delta vs. Soft Starter vs. VFD: Choosing a Motor Starting Method

PART OF THE GET YOUR MOTOR RUNNING SERIES

This article draws on Motor Starting Solutions, Part 3 of AuCom's Get Your Motor Running white paper series. It examines DOL, star-delta, soft starters and VFDs, focusing on how their characteristics influence the choice of motor starting method. The full white paper provides a more detailed comparison of six starting and control methods, including primary resistance and auto-transformer starting.

Explore the full Part 3 white paper →

 

A motor starting method can reduce the current drawn from the electrical supply and still produce an unsatisfactory start. Star-delta starting is a good example. It reduces current during the initial star-connected stage, but if the motor hasn't accelerated sufficiently before changing to delta, the transition can produce a substantial current and torque step. The initial current reduction may have achieved its purpose, yet the complete starting sequence may still cause problems.

Choosing between direct-on-line (DOL), star-delta, soft starters and variable frequency drives (VFDs) therefore involves more than comparing starting-current figures. Each method applies power to the motor differently, affecting the electrical supply, the torque available during acceleration and the driven equipment. With a VFD, those differences also extend to how the motor is controlled during normal operation.


What to consider when selecting a motor starting method
 

Before comparing technologies, it helps to establish what the installation will allow and what the driven machine requires. The electrical supply must accommodate the starting current and any resulting voltage disturbance, while the motor must develop enough torque to accelerate the load throughout the start. This is particularly important when considering reduced-voltage starting, as lowering the applied voltage reduces motor current but also reduces available torque. A current limit that looks acceptable from the supply side may leave too little accelerating torque for the machine.

Load inertia also affects how long the start takes. Even where sufficient torque is available, a lengthy acceleration can place additional thermal demands on the motor and starting equipment. The mechanical system must also be considered, as some machines tolerate an abrupt application of torque without difficulty, while others benefit from a more controlled starting or stopping sequence.

Finally, the operating requirements extend beyond the starting sequence itself. Some applications simply need the motor to reach its normal operating speed, while others require speed to vary with process demand. These considerations help determine which starting or control method is most appropriate for the installation.


DOL starting: when full voltage is acceptable

Direct-on-line (DOL) starting is the simplest of the four approaches, connecting the motor directly to the electrical supply and applying full voltage from standstill. The motor initially draws its locked-rotor current and develops its full-voltage starting torque. For many induction motors, this initial current is several times the normal full-load current and, depending on the supply network, can cause a noticeable voltage disturbance. The rapid application of torque may also place stress on couplings, transmissions and driven equipment.

Where the electrical supply can accommodate the starting current and the machinery can tolerate the resulting electrical and mechanical conditions, DOL remains a straightforward and practical solution without the need for additional starting equipment.


Star-delta starting: the importance of changeover

Star-delta starting offers a simple way to reduce the initial current drawn from the electrical supply. The windings of a suitable motor are initially connected in star, reducing the voltage across each winding before changing to delta for normal operation at full supply voltage. 

For a motor designed to run in delta at the available supply voltage, starting in star reduces the voltage across each winding to approximately 58% of its delta-connected value. Compared with direct-delta starting, the initial supply line current and starting torque are each approximately one-third of their full-voltage delta values.

That reduction can be useful, but the lower available torque is also the method's main limitation. The motor must develop sufficient torque in star to accelerate the driven load to an appropriate speed before changeover. If it has not accelerated sufficiently when the starter switches to delta, the resulting current and torque step can be significant.

The switching arrangement also affects the transition. In open-transition star-delta starting, the motor is briefly disconnected before being reconnected in delta. Residual motor voltage can contribute to additional electrical and mechanical transients at reconnection, depending on its relationship with the supply voltage. Closed-transition arrangements can reduce this effect.

Star-delta starting can be effective where the motor and load are suited to its fixed starting characteristics. However, reducing initial starting current does not guarantee a low-current transition to normal running.


Soft starters: adjustable control during starting

A solid-state soft starter provides more flexibility than a starter operating at fixed voltage levels. Using semiconductor switches, typically silicon-controlled rectifiers (SCRs), it regulates the voltage applied to the motor throughout the starting sequence. Depending on its design, control may be based on a preset voltage ramp or feedback from parameters such as current, torque or acceleration. This allows the starting behaviour to be adjusted to suit the motor and driven load, without the discrete electromechanical changeover associated with methods such as star-delta.

There are still limits to what voltage control can achieve. A soft starter controls the voltage applied to the motor without varying the supply frequency, and restricting current too aggressively can leave insufficient torque to accelerate the load. Similarly, setting a particular ramp time does not guarantee that the motor will reach speed within that time.

Many soft starters also offer controlled stopping functions, which can be useful where an abrupt stop would place additional stress on the mechanical or hydraulic system. Once starting is complete, the motor normally runs at supply frequency and essentially fixed speed. Many installations use a bypass arrangement to reduce losses in the starter's power electronics during normal operation.


VFDs: control beyond the starting sequence

A variable frequency drive (VFD) takes a different approach to motor starting by controlling both the voltage and frequency supplied to the motor. This allows it to manage motor speed during acceleration and regulate speed throughout normal operation. The capability is particularly valuable where changing motor speed is part of the process, such as a centrifugal pump responding to varying flow demand, a ventilation fan operating at different capacities or a conveyor running at adjustable production speeds.

Variable-speed operation isn't the only reason to consider a VFD. Some applications require substantial starting torque while placing strict limits on the current drawn from the electrical supply. A suitably selected VFD can help meet these requirements, even where the motor normally runs at one speed. Its starting characteristics, rather than the need for continuous speed adjustment, may be the deciding factor.

A VFD also introduces considerations beyond the starting sequence. Harmonic currents can affect the electrical supply, while the drive's output waveform and cable arrangement may influence motor insulation requirements and the need for additional filtering. Motor cooling also needs attention where the machine operates for extended periods at reduced speed, particularly if it relies on a shaft-mounted fan.

Unlike a soft starter, a VFD continues controlling the motor's supply voltage and frequency after the starting sequence is complete.

 


Choosing between the methods

Selecting a motor starting method requires an understanding of both the electrical supply and the driven load. The motor's torque-speed characteristic, the load's torque requirements and combined inertia determine how the system accelerates, while supply limitations and starting frequency influence the electrical and thermal demands. Where a method involves switching from reduced to full voltage, the motor must also accelerate sufficiently before transition.

These requirements need to be considered together. A method that reduces starting current may leave insufficient torque to accelerate the load, while one that meets the starting requirements may not provide the control needed during normal operation. If the process requires continuous speed regulation, that becomes a separate selection consideration beyond starting and stopping.


Explore the full comparison in Part 3

AuCom's Get Your Motor Running Part 3 white paper, Motor Starting Solutions, provides a more detailed technical comparison of six starting and control methods, including primary resistance and auto-transformer starting. It examines their current and torque characteristics, switching arrangements and the factors that influence selection.

RELATED ARTICLES